Okay, buckle up, because this one’s a ride. You know when you expect a mellow, easy-going bourbon, but instead, you get a bourbon that feels like it’s coming at you with a full-throttle surprise party? That’s this one. Seelbach’s Single Barrel Smoked Barrel comes out swinging with a smoky, peppery punch that’ll make you do a double-take. It’s the kind of bourbon that makes you go, “Wait, what just happened?” while still keeping you engaged enough to take that next sip. Let’s see if this one’s got staying power or if it’s just a confusing cocktail of flavors.

Nose

Ah, the nose. First whiff and it’s like walking into a peanut factory at a black pepper farm. Roasted peanuts and pepper immediately grab you by the nostrils and don’t let go. But wait, there’s more! Caramel creeps in, like it was just waiting for the right moment to make a guest appearance. And there’s this minty sensation… like chewing gum after a spicy meal, which is a weird but somehow perfect way to start things off. Root beer candy is also hanging around, probably wondering if it’s allowed to party. Is it weird? Yes. Is it interesting? Absolutely.

Palate

The palate isn’t shy, but it’s definitely got layers. Black pepper punches you in the mouth first, like that one friend who doesn’t know how to moderate their energy. Orange peel gives a little zing, and suddenly you’re in root beer candy land again (I swear, it’s like it’s following you). Roasted peanuts reappear, with dried dark cherries coming out of nowhere to add a little fruity twist. It’s sweet, it’s spicy, and it’s nutty in all the right places. If you’ve ever wondered what it’s like to sip a storm, this is your answer.

Finish

And then there’s the finish… weird. It’s like you’re about to hit a home run, but then the bat slips out of your hands and you miss the ball. It starts with some solid sweetness and spice, but then it fizzles out with a slight bitterness. If we’re being honest, it doesn’t quite stick the landing. But hey, it’s still warming, so there’s that.

Ratings

  • Dylan: 5.6
  • Scott: 5.1